"More Police Officers Will Die": Coroner's Stark Warning After 20-Year Veteran Officer Takes His Life Amidst Lengthy Investigation

Coroner's report links delayed disciplinary processes to rising mental health risks among police officers, as the tragic case of PC Martin Stubbs highlights calls for urgent reform.

The recent tragic death of PC Martin Stubbs has brought to light serious concerns over the prolonged investigation processes faced by serving police officers. The case, researched by Michael Brown, known as MentalHealthCop on X, has prompted West Yorkshire's Coroner to issue a Preventing Future Deaths report. The report cites the potential role of lengthy internal investigations in contributing to Stubbs' tragic decision to end his life. It sheds light on what many see as a deeply troubling issue for police forces across the UK.

The Case of PC Martin Stubbs: A Life Interrupted

PC Stubbs was a respected officer with over 20 years of service. He had just received a Long Service and Good Conduct medal before his arrest by West Yorkshire Police's Professional Standards Department (PSD) in November 2022. His arrest triggered an internal disciplinary process that, nearly two years later, remained unresolved. Stubbs tragically took his own life in August 2024, and the exact reasons for his arrest remain undisclosed, as does whether he disputed the allegations against him.

Stubbs' father, himself a former officer and now a civilian police employee, believes the drawn-out nature of the investigation was a significant factor in his son’s decision. The Coroner’s report echoes this, highlighting the psychological toll prolonged suspension and unresolved investigations can take on officers.

In his findings, the Coroner raised a fundamental concern about the length of time it took to conclude Stubbs’ case, emphasising the officer’s "legitimate expectation" for a swift resolution—a right afforded to all who undergo internal investigations. Stubbs' family has voiced their frustration, questioning whether delays are due to resourcing issues or an ingrained culture of procedural drift within PSD and the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).

A System Under Scrutiny: Lengthy Investigations and Their Impact on Mental Health

A Preventing Future Deaths report is not issued lightly. This statutory notice is a powerful warning that, unless PSD and IOPC investigations become timelier, more officers may be at risk of suffering similar fates. Stubbs' death, as detailed by Michael Brown’s research, is not an isolated incident; several other officers have taken their lives while under investigation, raising critical concerns about the support and mental health safeguards available to those facing disciplinary actions.

For many, the process remains distressingly prolonged. Cases involving police officers often stretch for years, with some dragging on indefinitely. In contrast, civilians under investigation for similar matters are usually subject to strict timelines designed to protect the rights and mental health of the accused. For police officers, however, the path remains marred by delays, leading to unnecessary stress, uncertainty, and mental strain.

Brown, a former police officer and mental health advocate, highlighted his concerns on social media: "A statutory notice issued because the Coroner is concerned that unless PSD / IOPC investigations are concluded in a more timely manner, more police officers will die—and tragically, we know Martin Stubbs was not the first officer to end their life whilst under investigation by PSD or the IOPC and I doubt he will be the last."

Brown’s words underscore the gravity of the situation. They should not and must not be ignored. The fact that a Coroner found it necessary to issue this statutory notice highlights a systemic issue that demands urgent reform. We need more action and we need it now.

The Need for Equal Timelines and Fair Processes

PC Stubbs’ tragic loss underscores the disparity in investigation timelines between police officers and civilians. While civilians benefit from statutory protections against prolonged investigations, police officers appear to lack similar guarantees. This lack of parity is deeply concerning and raises questions about whether officers who dedicate their lives to public service should endure such lengthy and mentally taxing processes.

PSD and IOPC have faced mounting criticism for what many see as excessive and disproportionate timelines, often far removed from the alleged issues at hand. While accountability within the police force remains paramount, critics argue that investigations should not extend for years, especially in cases where the problems do not appear to require such prolonged scrutiny. Officers who have committed themselves to serving the public should not feel that their only escape from the pressure and uncertainty is to take their own lives. We are letting them down.

Looking Ahead: A Call for Policy Change

This tragedy highlights a pressing need for reform. The mental health of serving officers, particularly those under investigation, must be given higher priority. Ensuring fair and timely processes for officers respects their commitment to the force and acknowledges the very real mental health pressures they face.

The question remains: will the authorities take the Coroner’s report and Michael Brown’s findings seriously? With growing scrutiny over PSD and IOPC investigation practices, there is hope that this tragic case will prompt meaningful change. For the families and colleagues of those like PC Martin Stubbs, reforms cannot come soon enough.

The Briefing Room

The Briefing Room offers our insights on this story and many others. With firsthand experience in both the emergency services and armed forces, we bring real-world knowledge to our reporting. The Briefing Room is exclusively for our paid subscribers, who also gain access to a subscriber-only chat where they can share their thoughts and chat with our team. As a reader-supported publication, we invite you to become a paid subscriber to help us continue our work—and to gain access to what we really think.

You Serve, You Suffer: The Unacceptable Reality for Our Police

When a 20-year veteran of the force like PC Martin Stubbs is driven to take his own life amid an endless internal investigation, it's time we had a no-nonsense discussion about what's happening to our police officers. This isn't about political correctness or bureaucratic formalities; this is about the raw truth of how we treat those who dedicate their lives to protecting us.

PC Stubbs wasn't just any officer; he was…